
When choosing an artist to compare and contrast to U2, I wanted one that would measure up to U2’s popularity and global reach. The first female artist I thought of was Madonna. I think she is similar to U2 in that she has been around for several decades and has a strong following throughout the world. Comparisons past that are pretty slim, however. Where as many U2 fans enjoy their songs because of the lyrics, I believe that many Madonna fans love her songs because they are entertaining. U2 has a strong following of both male and female listeners while the majority of Madonna’s fans are female. U2 has a specific sound that they have created and maintained. Madonna on the other hand seems to flow with the times. She’s talented at picking up what’s popular at the moment, whether it be a bit of a country twang or hip hop beat, but her songs continuously maintain top of chart status.
What type of demographic factors shape her fan base?
The bulk of Madonna’s fan base belongs to young women 16-30. Her songs are usually fun and upbeat making them good songs to play in the car with friends or out for a night on the town. She doesn’t necessarily have the same following with men. While I’m sure there are men that like her music, I think that most see her more as merely an entertainer and not as a respected musician. I feel as though she doesn’t have distinct class following but she has been known to reach out to bisexual and homosexual groups due to her speaking out on behalf of educating people about bisexuality (think of Madonna, Britney and Christina at the VMA’s). Madonna is certainly not known for being modest or meek, so I’d say she has few overly religious or pious fans. Much of her early work dealt with the irony of religion (thus her name being Madonna). She’s popular worldwide, the number one female artist of all time in the United Kingdom and has recently been inducted into the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame (1). Her song “Hung Up” reached #1 in 45 countries (2).
Do Madonna fans constitute a specific subculture?
I don’t believe that current Madonna fans have created their own subculture. I think she had more of a cult following when she first became popular. She really epitomized the eighties and its sexual revolution. A lot of people started to follow her fashion trends. Now, I think she is seen more of a music artist and not necessarily a fashion icon. Additionally, she doesn’t have the same shock value as she did previously. Whereas many of her songs and videos had strong sexual themes in them, she has somewhat toned them down to be a little more subtle and has relatively stopped any religious themes. Currently, I don’t believe her fans are part of a subculture. While she’s still a popular female artist, I feel that her influence on society has diminished.
1. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Madonna_(entertainer)
2. http://wiki.answers.com/Q/How_many_records_has_Madonna_sold_world_wide